Yes, yes, yes to women deacons

Some wonderful news came out of the Vatican on Thursday. During a meeting with some 900 leaders of the world’s congregations of Catholic women religious, Pope Francis announced he will create a commission to study the possibility of allowing women to serve as deacons in the Catholic Church.
Many church historians have being saying for decades that there is abundant evidence that women served as deacons in the early centuries of the church. The apostle Paul mentions one such woman, Phoebe, in his letter to the Romans.
The permanent diocanate was retored to the church after Vatican II and there are now over 40,000 male permanent deacons ministering in parishes and dioceses throughout the world. Permanent deacons cannot say Mass, anoint or hear confession, but they are able to baptize, preside at marriages and funerals, proclaim the Gospel and preach during various liturgies.
Women deacons would be able to do these very same things.
How wonderful would that be! Imagine a woman in vestments proclaiming the Gospel and preaching in St Peter’s in Rome! The image of a church transformed that would send out.
What kinds of things could women deacons preach on? In the words of Fr James Martin, S.J.: “Everything of course, like male deacons! But imagine them preaching on the following: The Annunciation, the Visitation, the Nativity, Mary Magdalene, Mary and Martha, the Woman at the Well, the Syrophoenician woman, the appearance of the Risen Christ to Mary Magdalene, and on and on. Women deacons could preach on anything, like male deacons, but how I long to hear them preach on Jesus and on women in the New Testament.”
One of the most offputting aspects of major church liturgies is the rows of robed male clerics with not a single woman in sight. I don’t know how women put up with it. It’s why I choose not to concelebrate at Mass, if I don’t have to.
Of course, it is early days and all the pope has done is announce his intention to form a commission to study the possibility of women deacons. The commission may amount to nothing in the end, or propose no change in the status quo.
But it’s good to dream.
When one considers the question of women and the Catholic Church today, some things are obvious. First, women not only make up a significant majority of those who attend Mass and the sacraments week in week out, they play the primary role in handing on the faith. Without women the Catholic Church would be moribund or close to it.
Second, women have traditionally done much of the church’s dirty work. Think of religious education (nuns and catechists); church and parish administration (secretaries); upkeep and decoration of churches (altar societies and Martha Ministers), care of priests (housekeepers and helpers). If these women downed tools tomorrow the church would scarcely be able to function.
Three, women continue to have a tremendous love for the church. They show this not just by continuing to occupy the pews every Sunday and doing most of the church’s dirty work, but also by the number who serve on parish pastoral councils, teach religion in schools, become extraordinary ministers of the Word and Eucharist, do voluntary work and take courses in theology.
Indeed, the commitment and enthusiasm of so many women is extraordinary given that they are second-class members of their own church. The Catholic Church is the last great western institution that systematically discriminates against women. 
It is no longer good enough to pay lip service to the dignity and vocation of women in the church, as church leaders have tended to do. Real and equal involvement in the church is not a privilege women must earn but a right that belongs to them by virtue of their creation in the image of God and their cooperation into Christ through baptism. Ordaining women to the diaconate would be a wonderful step in the right direction.

Author: frommypulpit

I'm a Redemptorist preacher and writer, with an interest in history, politics, and sport, who is living with chronic back pain.

One thought on “Yes, yes, yes to women deacons”

  1. Couldn’t agree more Gerry.

    It remains to be seen what his intentions are but he is clearly fighting for a more gender equitable social status for women in South/Latin America currently and addressing this issue within Western culture shows that he is at least willing to inspire further debate. This provides an opening for those groups out there who have been fighting for decades to enact this reform within the RCC.

    There is a doorway open so now is not the time to watch the Pope in awe. Now is the time to bring forth all arguments while the Pope is wearing this particular hat. If there were a message to pass along, it would be that, in my mind.

    How can Canon Law pretend to be meaningful when it discriminates and is gender biased? Where in the bible did Christ discriminate? He picked male apostles but wasn’t this at a time where the followers of his belief system were seen as so conceivably controversial, they were taking their lives in their own hands? Is it any wonder they had to leave their families to spread the word? Does this controversy still exist? Then what is the fundamental reason for discrimination?

    This controversy still exists but has gone silent. Is not elitism in full force to this day? Militarization through tax collection, hasn’t disappeared. Economic disparity and strategic poverty still rule among a certain class. Who among you speaks of this? Are these too controversial a topic?

    Some would beg to argue that the world is currently in the state it’s in because of the patriarchal society we live in. Imagine if Jesus’s message was the importance of a matriarch. I know many clans of North American Aboriginals, before the European man arrived, were headed by a chief (male) but he was put in power by the women of the clan and removed if they were not happy with his management style. Women were the spiritual centres of their respective clans; the political power was in the hands of the clan mothers.

    I guess we can only wish that the Papacy could be presided over in such a fashion. The health and well-being of the planet depends on it, possibly. I have many questions but few are quick to answer.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: